The Monkey’s been asking The Questions — The Questions, that is, that I’ve been waiting for.
When I was a little girl, The Questions came first thing one morning. It was like a bell went off — DING: I realized I, and everyone around me, was going to die one day. My head started to spin as I went through all the people I love. All of them were going to die one day. My Great Grandma Fanny was already 96! My DOG Belle was 8! My PARENTS! OMG, MY PARENTS!
I ran to my parents’ room, gripping my favourite doll, “Marcus Mouse” — who happened to have a bell attached to his paw. DING DING DING DING DING. I ran to my parents’ room and jumped into the bed between them, and sobbed.
“When am I going to die? I don’t want to die! Belle’s already 8 years old. And soon she’s going to be 9 and then 10 and then 14 and then she’s going to DIE-HIE-HIE-HA-HA-WAHHHHH!” I don’t remember a thing my parents told me to pacify the anxiety and sadness. I just remember realizing that I was going to have to figure out how to live with all this new knowledge.
I now know how helpless my mother felt that morning. I was probably in Grade One already. The Monkey is only FOUR.
She’s been obsessed with death and dying since we lost Tigger. She would taunt me with hard questions about Tigger’s death, and laugh because she knew she was being a nutball…. She never reflected it all back on herself, thank GOD. Until now.
Yesterday, in the car — it happened. As she asked me Question after HARD Question (in panic and tears), I couldn’t help but notice I felt half there, and half transported back into my childhood, to that day when I realized that my life was finite. I can’t even bear to put her questions into writing.
I had to think quickly. On the spot.
“We die when we’re ready,” I said, “when our souls are ready, and usually when we’re really really old.”
“One hundred and ten, Mama?”
“Or one hundred and fifty! Who knows. But, in one way or another, you’ll be ready, so you don’t have to worry, Monkey.”
But this didn’t help, and the questions got worse, and more intense, and more horrifying. And, in the end, all I could say was this:
“Monkey, I love you. I’m here. I’m with you.”
And it worked.
She was having major anxiety — and, thankfully, I know anxiety. I needed to bring her back to the present. Since then, The Questions haven’t returned. So far. Today.
There are NO good go-to answers for The Questions, I don’t think. When they come, they’re here to stay, emerging now and then, like waves of the ocean. The only thing I can do is bring her back, say, 150 years, to now — to the present and to love.
*On a lighter note (GAH!), if you look closely at the picture above, you’ll see a little blond untamable shock of hair. Her little brother is oblivious to all the Questions…. Ignorance is bliss.











































SciFi Dad said, February 24th, 2010 at 3:54 pm
It’s never easy when they ask. My daughter occasionally asks about my grandmother (who died when my daughter was around 18 months, so there’s photos of them together and what not), and I always just explain that she’s not here anymore, and that I miss her. We haven’t needed to get into the whole afterlife stuff (yet).
Renee said, February 24th, 2010 at 5:01 pm
mine hasn’t asked me about death. But her grandmother recently passed away, so we did talk about it then. Luckily we had recently seen Titanic. In the final scene where Rose dies and goes back to the ship and meets everyone and Jack is waiting for her. I told DD that’s what heaven is like. It worked. I believe that when MIL died that FIL was waiting for her just like that scene.
Hugs! I think you did good with Monkey.
.-= Renee´s last blog ..DH is so funny… =-.
Heather said, February 24th, 2010 at 5:14 pm
I really like that you reassured her that she will be ready. I’m totally stealing that one, one day.
Such a serious little monkey you’ve got.
.-= Heather´s last blog ..Help for Haiti =-.
it'sgrandma said, February 24th, 2010 at 8:06 pm
Well done, sweetheart!!! xoxoxo
Dina said, February 24th, 2010 at 8:51 pm
Yikes! Really well done! I don’t know what I would’ve done in that situation!
((((Hugs)))))
Alyssa said, February 24th, 2010 at 9:57 pm
That is so difficult for me, too. My daughter is four and has questioned intensely about death. Thankfully after several sessions she hasn’t asked again…I wonder if her curiosity was satisfied or she sensed my discomfort with it…I feel anxiety even reading this post. It’s tough!
I agree with previous comments that you handled it well. (but, hey, what do I know?)
.-= Alyssa´s last blog ..Happy Chinese New Year! =-.
Maria said, February 25th, 2010 at 10:53 am
My kids ask off & on but never in a panic. Then I had the worst terrible mom moment EVER! I was yelling at them one day about not listening when I mumbled “you kids are going to give me a heart attack”. A few days later, maybe even a week later, my little guy (3) started crying out of the blue because he didn’t want me to have a heart attack and die. He was soooo upset that my eyes are tearing up now as I write this. I have never felt so horrible!!! I reassured him that I was fine & that won’t happen, thankfully he has not brought it up ever again & I am much more careful in what I say. It is so hard parenting at times!
Julie said, February 25th, 2010 at 1:44 pm
“I love you. I’m here. I’m with you.”
that is gold as far as i’m concerned. my 4 1/2 year old asks questions about grammie all the time (she passed last summer) and i told her that her body is in the ground and what made her who she is (i called it her ghost as that’s a word she understands) is still with us like an angel. we can’t see her but she’s able to visit us.
she hasn’t asked about herself dying yet (whew) but your sentence is what i’m going to tell her when i explain that to her.
Multi-Tasking Mommy said, February 25th, 2010 at 3:03 pm
Oh, I can truly empathize with you. My daughter’s same question came while I was driving too and it was, “Mommy, when are you going to die?”. Just last week she asked me if I was going to be dead when she had babies of her own.
I don’t remember exactly what I said to her for the first question, something like – “I don’t plan on dying any time soon. Mommy’s here and I love you!” This seemed to keep her happy.
She asks about death more regularly than I’m comfortable with, but it is so healthy to talk about it. It’s just so hard to know what to say or how to say it. And for me, I don’t think well on my feet at all!
Good luck!
.-= Multi-Tasking Mommy´s last blog ..Works for Me Wednesday: Fridge Magnet Storage =-.
LAVENDULA said, February 25th, 2010 at 3:13 pm
thats always such a hard talk to have with our children.and i have found that each one that has asked required different answers and information the changeling who is now 9 was so terrified that her dad or i would die that she couldn’t sleep and spent almost a month sleeping with us or her big sister.and she would wake at night and come in my room to make certain i was still alive …stinkerbell hasn’t asked about herself yet just great granny who died 2.5 years ago. i think you handled that beautifully with monkey xo
Eden Spodek said, February 25th, 2010 at 7:54 pm
My kids are much older and they’ve never asked before – thank goodness – I’m not sure I would have responded with such grace and your responses were golden. Thanks for sharing.
I’ve had conversations with both of them about loved ones and death in the context of relatives they’ve never met or don’t remember. I’ve always ended on a note of comfort and reassurance.
.-= Eden Spodek´s last blog ..Adventures in homemade baby food =-.
Jenifer said, February 26th, 2010 at 11:39 am
Such tough questions…I think you answered just right.
.-= Jenifer´s last blog ..Summer lovin’ and the forgettin’ is easy =-.
Chantal said, February 28th, 2010 at 1:05 pm
That is so hard. My 4 year old often talks about my grandfather who died last year. He was close to him and remembers. He will say “But you wont’ die right mommy?” and I really have no good answer for that. Do I say, well yes I will and freak him out. Or say no I won’t and set him up for lifelong issues. I usually just tell him I won’t die for a long long time, and pray that I am right.
.-= Chantal´s last blog ..Childrens book giveaway =-.
Jonathan said, March 2nd, 2010 at 11:03 am
We are lucky in some ways – we have chickens in our back garden, and a fox has got in more than once, and decimated them. The kids learned the way of the world early because of it, and took it on the chin.
.-= Jonathan´s last blog ..The many and varied facets of my idiocy =-.
Francis said, March 9th, 2010 at 12:28 pm
I remember that moment when I was a kid! I was AWFUL! I too ran to my parents room and freaked out per say. I think it happens to all of us, no? I guess we all react differently, but my experience was very similar to yours!
.-= Francis´s last blog ..Chef Knife Sets =-.